I can’t be the only one to think about this when I am getting ready for a fishing trip. Would I rather catch “the big one” or would I rather catch a steady stream of fish and hit my limit? The one monster fish could land me in the record books if I do well enough. That’s a fishing story I could get tattooed on me, or at least wear a button that says “Ask me about my state record fish”.
On the other hand, if we do really well, catching the limit on fish would fill up my freezer. And at (insert large number here) for the limit, I won’t even hardly have time to sit down if I’m catching them all day. That doesn’t even include the limit on a different kind of species I could inadvertently catch even though I’m not targeting them! Whether you’re somebody who relishes that big fish or someone who would rather be engaged in a regular catch, let’s at least hear out each side.
For “The Big One”
Marathon fishing days can lead to a lot of time talking with friends or inside our own minds. Those stretches of time where you’ll change out gear to find something that works. Is waiting the best part of fishing? No, not really. But it is part of the experience. You go an hour, two…six. Maybe without any kind of bite. And then, BAM. Your rod gets absolutely slammed. The fight is like nothing you’ve come across before. You think to yourself you must be snagged up or one of some different species because the one you’re targeting simply does not fight like this.
Then, the fish surfaces. It looks like something that’s been hitting the $5 buffets in Vegas and isn’t afraid to go back for thirds or fourths. It gets netted and you think to yourself, “How in the world did I catch this”. You grin, you cheer, you motion for everybody you’re fishing with to take a look. It’s easily the story of the day, probably the story of your year. The old adage, I’ve got bigger fish to fry, tells you everything you need to know about moving on to bigger and better things.
In fact, there’s an argument about the many that will probably resonate with many of you. It’s probably the most obvious argument because it’s the argument in favor of The Big One. It hit me as I was looking back in my photo album trying to justify an argument for the many. Who takes photos of a bunch of small fish? Sure, maybe you’ll take the first one to show you did in fact catch something. Or if you remember at the end of the day you’ll remember to line up all the fish on the dock. But, that’s when you’re already trying to bring the boat in, manage the queue of vehicles trying to get in and out, secure the boat to the trailer, put away the gear, and generally not look like a rookie.
These kinds of photos are great for a guide service to show they get folks on the water and into fish, which is certainly what you would hope for. But to the layman, the appeal really doesn’t seem to be there. Bystanders could look at your spread of fish and comment on you having had a good day, catching near or at the limit is great, but will silently be judging you and think about the mammoth they caught relative to the ho-hum size of the fish you brought in. It’s way more common and photo-worthy to post that one huge fish, rather than the compilation of small to average-sized fish. The one that makes people say “Wow!” But those fish that make everyone on the boat stop and admire it?
Those are the kind of kodak moments you’ll stop everything you’re doing to make sure you document the occasion. Look at any guide service, they post pictures of the legendary fish. State records? Do I need to say anymore? Where else can common folks like us hold a record for 30 or more years, because it sure won’t be in home runs for touchdown passes. But one nice fish can put our names in the record books. And it could be at any moment. Really, if we don’t fish for the clout and sense of self-worth, why bother fishing at all?
For “The Many”
Who among us doesn’t like pulling in their catch? I mean that’s the main objective of fishing, isn’t it? To bring in something on your line besides seaweed or a bait-less hook? You’re out with some friends, or maybe a kid who hasn’t fished much. An entertaining day with a cooler full of fish is the fastest way to hook someone else into this great sport.
When you get to the point in the day where everyone on the boat is looking at each other and asking whose turn it is, you know you’re in the middle of an awesome fishing adventure. In this fishing reality, we’ve built for ourselves, everyone gets a chance to participate, and everyone gets to enjoy a tasty dinner (if keeping your catch is your thing). The banter picks up. The camaraderie builds. Everyone is in great spirits and appreciates the constant action.
There isn’t that sense of if we catch something but instead, when are we going to catch the next one? You pass by some other boats in the water and exchange the usual conversation. What are you using, how has the bite been, that kind of stuff. Instead of the meh response of just doing OK with a few bites here and there you proudly share that the bite has been insane and you’re getting hit on every rod at every depth with every lure you’re putting in the water.
The other boat slowly trudges by with expressionless faces as they’ve had the exact opposite kind of experience on the day. In fact, they share that they’ve been camping throughout the weekend and haven’t so much as seen a fish surface or a blip on the fish finder. And like clockwork, your casual conversation is broken up because, well, you’ve got another bite to attend to.
Another area to think about as to why we should be vying for the huge number of fish rather than the huge fish is the likelihood of each happening. We have all caught some big fish, me included. But many more of us, and more often, I would wager have had days where we limited out or went through an insane bite. Those fishing outings where you continuously pull in solid fish. The kind of fish that offers a good fight and makes for a consistent fun experience. For every day where a single big fish gets caught, there seems to be exponentially more multi-fish days out on the water. That consistency can’t be overlooked or overshadowed when we start those early mornings.
There you have it. The pros and cons of catching The Big One vs catching The Many. What do you think? Are you the kind of person who wants to hang his hat on a fish that you’ll talk about for the rest of your life? Or are you the kind of person who pulls in a huge quantity of fish and sees that as a day well spent out on the water? Let’s at least end with some common ground. In each of these scenarios, both kinds of anglers spent the day fishing. They can both be happy about that.
